The Supreme Court in the United States of America will hold an oral hearing in a case that one legal expert called "the most important Supreme Court case on homelessness in at least 40 years," foreign media write.
The issue before the court is the constitutionality of ordinances in an Oregon city that prevent homeless people from using blankets, pillows or cardboard boxes to protect themselves from the elements while sleeping inside city limits. In defending the ordinances, the city argues that the laws simply prohibit camping on public land for anyone.
However, the other side in the case argues that the ordinances effectively make homelessness a crime in the city.
The court's decision could have a significant impact not only in the small town of Grants Pass, Oregon, whose ordinances are being challenged, but also in cities across the United States, where similar laws have become increasingly common.
Model "camping" laws have been adopted more widely in recent years as state and local governments try to deal with double-digit increases in homelessness. Data released by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Affairs indicates that more than 600.000 people in the United States were homeless on a single night in 2023.
Monday's court case comes before judges in Grants Pass, a town of just under 40.000 in southwestern Oregon. With an unemployment rate of one percent and almost no affordable housing, the city has up to 600 people who are homeless. The chief operating officer of a non-profit organization in the county where the city is located, which provides services to people who are homeless, said in a statement he filed in the case that almost all people who are homeless and live in the city do so involuntarily. "There is simply no place in Grants Pass where I can find affordable housing or shelter." They don't choose to live on the streets or in the woods,” said the nonprofit's COO.
Possible land access bans
At a 2013 city council meeting, the city president suggested "we make them uncomfortable enough in our city that they want to go further down the road." The city has decided to increase enforcement of ordinances that prohibit the use of blankets, pillows and even cardboard boxes while sleeping inside the city.
The ordinances provide for a fine of $295 for violations; the penalty increases to $537,60 if unpaid. After two reports, Grants Pass police can issue an order barring an individual from city land; violation of that order exposes the individual to conviction for felony trespassing, which carries penalties of up to 30 days in jail and a $1250 fine.
The Gloria Johnson case
In 2018, the United States Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit ruled in the case of Martin v. City of Boise that the Eighth Amendment's prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment prohibits the imposition of criminal sanctions for sitting or sleeping outside on homeless people who do not have access to shelters.
After the court's decision in the Boyce case, John Logan and Gloria Johnson (along with Debricka Blake, who has since passed away) went to federal court in Oregon to challenge the constitutionality of the City of Grants Pass ordinance on their behalf and on behalf of others who involuntarily homeless in Grants Pass. Logan was intermittently homeless in the city for over a decade and sometimes slept in his truck outside of the city to avoid being fined and fined for sleeping in his truck inside the city.
After being unable to find other housing she could afford, Johnson slept in her van, where ordinances were enforced against her "dozens of times."