The biggest problems, which have burdened the media market and the general functioning of the media in the region for decades, are the deep political polarization and connection of the media with political elites, biased reporting, non-transparent ownership, economic insecurity and low salaries, increasingly frequent physical and digital attacks on journalists, humiliation of professional standards and norms, as well as a problematic regulatory framework that is not adequately applied, does not ensure full protection of independent journalism, nor full media freedom. What are the biggest problems of each country? How similar are their situations, and how are they different?
BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA
ADVOCACY JOURNALISM AND PRESSURES
All relevant reports of international organizations and bodies in the EU show that media freedom in BiH is threatened, that journalists are under constant pressure, that the general state of media freedom is alarming, especially when it comes to the law criminalizing defamation in Republika Srpska. Citizens of BiH do not trust the media, they believe that they are burdened with censorship and self-censorship, which occur due to strong political and economic influences. They also believe that a large number of informative TV shows are just political propaganda, and that hate speech, false information and biased reporting prevail in other segments as well.
In one of the latest surveys of public opinion in Bosnia and Herzegovina, it is highlighted that the citizens evaluate the information published by the media in Bosnia and Herzegovina as "incitement" and that everyone, including public services, depends in different ways on political and economic interest groups and powerful people. It is also alarming that only four years ago, in a similar survey, the citizens of BiH stated that they support violence against journalists, that is, that it is acceptable to hit a journalist. However, this has changed in recent research - the only progress, it seems, is that the citizens of Bosnia and Herzegovina now think that any form of violence against journalists is unacceptable.
At the same time, the big problem of non-transparency of media ownership in Bosnia and Herzegovina is reflected primarily in the online sphere, where over 270 informational web portals have no imprint, so no data on editors and journalists, as the analysis of Radio Free Europe shows. In addition, a huge problem is the hate speech that is rampant in the comments of those portals, because no one moderates them or takes care of public communication and messages that go out on the air. Professional journalism in BiH has been affected by the trend of extradition, "copy-paste journalism" and the race for profit, as Cenzolovka once wrote, which, in combination with the aforementioned strong political and economic dependence, have led to a complete lowering of ethical standards and norms. Political turbulence in this country continues to affect strong ethno-national and party polarization, which spills over into the media sector and public opinion.
In the analysis of Mediacenter Sarajevo, which a few years ago researched hate narratives in the media and comments on portals in Bosnia and Herzegovina, hate speech and negative propaganda against certain national and ethnic groups is particularly problematic, fueling tensions in society. Lejla Turčilo and Belma Buljubasic, professors at the University of Sarajevo, recently concluded in their book about the media in BiH that all these problems directly reflect on the credibility of the media, and that the phenomena of advocacy journalism instead of professional reporting, the instrumentalization of private media and "media racketeering", the politicization of public services and the underdevelopment of journalism as an autonomous profession.
MONTENEGRO
WHO OWNS THE MEDIA
The media in Montenegro is quite politicized and polarized, with insufficiently developed professional journalism and objective reporting on socio-political issues. Attacks on journalists, financing of media from state funds, problems in self-regulation of the market, as well as the long-term decline of RTCG as a public service make any changes in the Montenegrin media market difficult. In addition, media regulation is not sufficiently harmonized with European standards, and besides, the media laws do not foresee the solution of the most important problems. This particularly refers to the situation in the Montenegrin public service and the criteria for the selection of RTCG council members, which would ensure its independence. One of the biggest paradoxes of the Montenegrin media scene is that self-regulatory bodies are financed from the budget, which renders the concept of self-regulation meaningless.
On the other hand, BIRN's research shows that the most influential private media in Montenegro are mostly foreign owned or controlled. The dominance of foreign media ownership is one of the main reasons why citizens of Montenegro are worried about the state of the media. Similar to other countries in the region, there are no adequate mechanisms in Montenegro that enable the transparency of media ownership, especially the one related to online media. One of the biggest problems is precisely the hidden ownership of web portals and the complete absence of data on natural persons as media owners. And unlike all other countries in the region, the Montenegrin authorities have banned the broadcasting of Russian media, including Rasha Today Balkan and Sputnik. All public broadcasters had to exclude the contents of Russian media, and the "black list" includes, in addition to RT and Spunjik services, services in the Arabic language. According to Montenegrin media experts, the Agency for Electronic Media (a counterpart of REM) is not completely independent and impartial in its work, nor does it respond adequately to hate speech and inappropriate content broadcast on regional TV stations. One of the exceptions is the decision of the Agency for Electronic Media, which for six months banned the broadcast of some programs of Happy TV, which has a national frequency in Serbia.
NORTH MACEDONIA
AS ELSEWHERE, ONLY BETTER
According to the latest "Reporter without Borders" media freedom index, North Macedonia occupies the best position in relation to the countries of the former Yugoslavia - it ranks 36th out of 180 places. It is even better than Slovenia and Croatia, which are members of the EU, and far better than Bosnia and Herzegovina, Montenegro and Serbia, which is the worst positioned of all the Balkan countries (Serbia is in 98th place).
The media market in Macedonia, as in other neighboring countries, is overloaded with the number of media in relation to the geographical area and the size of the market, and commercial media are subject to political and economic pressures. The online sphere allows somewhat freer journalism, but like in other countries of the former Yugoslavia, it is burdened with hate speech, inciting narratives and a lack of comment moderation. Clientelism and connection with power centers have a very large influence on the spread of propaganda and misinformation. The latest reports of international organizations show that according to the level of media literacy, North Macedonia ranks last among all European countries. The main problems burdening the Macedonian media scene are the same as in others: insufficient money for an independent and sustainable media business, local government subsidies that are allocated in a non-transparent manner and state advertising, lack of professional journalists and media workers, insufficiently developed digital journalism skills, decline trust even in local media.
CROATIA
SLAPP LAWSUITS ARE POURING
Croatia holds the record in Europe when it comes to proceedings against media and journalists. According to a report by Radio Free Europe, in the middle of 2023 there were as many as 945 proceedings, or SLAPP lawsuits, brought against Croatian media by individuals and companies, mostly from the corporate world. The goal of SLAPP lawsuits is to discourage and exhaust the already poor media through protracted proceedings and financial extortion. According to the "Media Freedom Rapid Response" report, violations of media freedom in Croatia are mostly influenced by politicians and high government officials, who use every opportunity to discredit and insult journalists who report critically on the government.
The most prominent among them, Croatian Prime Minister Andrej Plenković, often insults journalists in public addresses and at press conferences, and recently caused a real storm when he announced changes to the Criminal Code and the Criminal Procedure Code, according to which leaking information from judicial investigations will become a criminal offense. , with the aim that information from the investigation no longer goes out to the media in an uncontrolled and deliberate manner. The Croatian Journalists' Association strongly reacted to Plenković's announcement, stating that the information obtained by journalists and published in the media cannot be labeled as "leaking information", and that, as they claim, Plenković obviously wants to be "the editor-in-chief of all Croatian media" and in this way directly endangers journalism and threatens the media.
Other international missions have confirmed that, although a member of the EU, Croatia lags behind countries that have a free media environment. The biggest problems are the reform of media laws, the lack of transparency of state advertising in the media, the insufficient independence of HRT as a public service, as well as the politicized appointment of members of the Agency for Electronic Media.
SLOVENIA
AFTER JANŠA, THE NEW LAW
The propaganda media network in Slovenia - which was linked to the funds of the Ministry of Culture, state-owned companies, the former political elite and Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán - degraded media freedom in that country and established market self-regulation mechanisms. The issue of financing hate speech in the media was also raised before the Slovenian parliament, and the EU reacted to threats and attempts at media lynching and disciplining certain media.
The Slovenian media fared the worst during the mandate of Prime Minister Janez Janša, who constantly complained that journalists criticized him too much. He questioned the financing of the Slovenian news agency, because at one time he blocked the funds that were necessary for its functioning. Slanders against journalists and editors, numerous accusations by the media for biased reporting, as well as the politicization of the process of appointing members of the program council and the supervisory board of the public service RTVSLO contributed to the fact that the Slovenian media recorded a decline in the world indices of media freedom. During 2022, the employees of RTVSLO went on strike, because the survival of this company was in danger, and above all because of the interference of Prime Minister Janša and politics in general in the program content of national television. Janša waged his war against journalists he didn't like by publicly accusing the Slovenian news agency STA on Twitter of being a "national scumbag", and calling the public service an "irresponsible spreader of the virus", as the Serbian media once wrote. In turn, he was called "Prime Minister Tvito", which is a combination of the words Twitter and Tito, which symbolized Janša's political and media ambitions. From the middle of 2022, after the departure of Janša from power, preparations began for a new law on public media service, which would guarantee greater independence and depoliticization. A referendum was held on this issue, where even 62 percent of Slovenians clearly opted for strengthening the public media service and reducing political influence on the media, so the law was adopted in June 2023.
SERBIA
COMPLETE CAPTURE OF THE MEDIA SPACE
For decades, the Serbian media market has been crowded with a huge number of poor and unsustainable media. The low degree of independence and media freedom, widespread political and economic pressures, political instrumentalization of the media, as well as court proceedings against journalists, along with widespread clientelism, biased reporting and captive institutions depict the complete captivity of the media space.
Serbian media is almost at the bottom of the world indexes of media freedom, so last year Serbia moved from the group of "problematic" countries to the category of "difficult situation" when it comes to professional journalism, media freedom and safety of journalists. The media scene is extremely polarized, reporting is focused on political elites, not the needs of citizens.
The latest analysis by the Belgrade Center for Security Policy and Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, which touched upon the issue of the domestic media scene in the publication "The Future of Serbia", shows that among the main problems are first and foremost widespread political and economic pressures on the media, a large concentration of media ownership, state advertising in the media and non-transparent giving of money from the budget to eligible media, but also self-censorship and frequent attacks by political officials and high-ranking government officials on critical journalists and the media.
The competent Regulatory Body for Electronic Media does not respond to hate speech, violation of professional standards and norms, and the institution itself is neither politically independent nor sufficiently transparent in its work. The state has a huge influence on the media market, even through the recently adopted media laws that allowed it to once again enter the ownership of the media. Journalists are less and less safe, and there is a lack of functional protection mechanisms. The media is highly instrumentalized for propaganda purposes, the tabloidization of the content prevails, but also the tabloid settlement of the political powers with dissenters.
The recently adopted Rulebook REM no longer prescribes the obligation for broadcasters to have 20 percent of quality programming, which until recently was one of the main conditions for obtaining a national frequency. This means that televisions no longer have to have cultural, educational, children's, or documentary programs, but only reality programs and political propaganda, and on the basis of such a program structure, get a national frequency. There are more and more SLAPP proceedings against journalists and media organizations, and journalism in general lags behind the world trends of digital transformation of journalism and media, as well as necessary changes in newsrooms when it comes to adapting to the digital age and new contents.
The author is an associate professor at the Faculty of Political Sciences at the University of Belgrade