Pregnancy, childbirth and pregnancy loss are among the most sensitive experiences in a woman's life. In those moments, she is often in pain, fear and uncertainty, relying on the knowledge and help of health workers. Therefore, the way doctors, midwives and other staff address her, inform her and involve her in decision-making can significantly affect not only her immediate experience, but also her physical and mental health after leaving the hospital.
...Sanja Radivojevic
Most women from healthcare workers they expect expertise, but also for someone to explain what is happening, answer questions and preserve their privacy and dignity. However, women's testimonies show that in gynecological-obstetrical institutions insults and belittling, neglect of reported pain, interventions without proper explanation, lack of privacy and situations in which a woman during childbirth or pregnancy loss is left without the necessary help and supervision still occur.
The term obstetric violence is used more and more frequently for such procedures. In Serbia, it is not the name of a separate criminal offense, nor is it defined as a separate legal term by the Law on Patients' Rights. This does not mean, however, that such behavior is legally permissible or without consequences. One event can simultaneously represent a violation of several rights of the patient, a violation of professional standards, a basis for disciplinary or civil liability, and in the most serious cases, a basis for criminal liability.
The World Health Organization warns that disrespect and abuse of women during childbirth can threaten their rights to life, health, bodily integrity, privacy, dignity and protection from discrimination. Respect for the patient is therefore not only a question of kindness or goodwill of an individual healthcare worker. It is an integral part of quality and safe health care.
WHAT DO WE MEAN BY OBSTETRICAL VIOLENCE
Childbirth and other obstetric procedures can be painful, unpredictable and medically demanding. An unfavorable outcome in itself does not prove that a professional error was made, just as every unpleasant experience does not constitute obstetric violence. On the other hand, overcrowding in the maternity ward, lack of staff or urgency cannot justify in advance insulting, ignoring serious symptoms, punishing the woman for the way she reacts to pain or carrying out an intervention without the necessary explanation.
When evaluating the treatment of the patient, it is necessary to separate several questions. The first is whether the medical measure was professionally justified and properly implemented. The second is whether the woman received an intelligible notice in a timely manner and gave valid consent. The third is whether her dignity, privacy and right to humane care were preserved during the procedure.
A medically justified intervention can be carried out in violation of her rights if the woman is not explained what is being done and why, or if she is exposed to humiliation during the intervention. Conversely, rude or abusive behavior does not necessarily mean that a professional error has been made, but it can still represent unacceptable and unethical behavior that should be investigated.
Obstetric violence or other violation of rights can be indicated by interventions without explanation and consent when there was no urgency, ignoring calls for help, denying a reasonably available means of pain relief without explanation, insulting, mocking, intimidating a woman, as well as an examination or procedure in front of other people without the need and protection of privacy.
Particularly difficult are situations in which physical force is used or a woman's movement is restricted without medical justification, when she is left without the necessary supervision during childbirth or pregnancy loss, or when she is exposed to discrimination due to disability, ethnicity, language, property status, age, marital status or other personal characteristics.
Context is always important. Therefore, a specific case cannot be reliably assessed based on only one sentence or an isolated procedure. It is necessary to review the medical documentation, the course of events, the condition of the patient, the degree of urgency, professional standards and the statements of the persons present.
WHAT RIGHTS DO WOMEN HAVE IN THE MATERNITY CENTER
By entering a maternity ward or a gynecological-obstetrical clinic, a woman does not give up her rights to admission. She still has the right to know what is being proposed to her and why, to participate in decisions about her body, to have her privacy protected, to have her pain alleviated and to be treated with dignity. The urgency or severity of the situation may affect the way of providing help, but it does not abolish the patient's human dignity.
One of the fundamental rights is the right to notice. The healthcare worker should explain the diagnosis and prognosis, the goal and benefit of the proposed measure, how long it lasts, what risks and possible consequences it carries, what other possibilities exist and what can happen if the measure is not taken. The explanation must be given in a language the woman understands and early enough for her to ask questions and make a decision. Sentences such as "it must", "don't ask anything" or "everyone signs it" are not a substitute for notice. Even a signature on a pre-prepared form does not automatically mean that consent is informed if there was no discussion and a real possibility that the patient understood the proposed procedure.
As a rule, a medical measure must not be taken without the patient's consent. Consent must be free and based on prior notice, and refer to a specific measure. Acceptance of admission to the hospital or one intervention is not a blank consent for everything that may be undertaken later. The patient can also refuse the proposed measure after the consequences of such a decision are explained to her, as well as revoke the previously given consent, in accordance with the law.
Exceptions exist when a woman is unable to communicate her will, and a medical measure is urgently needed, as well as in other cases expressly regulated by law. However, the exception must not become the rule just because it is easier for the healthcare staff.
The patient has the right to a dignified relationship. Yelling, insults, ridicule, threats, comments about her sex life, marital status, origin or number of children are not part of the treatment. Statements in which pain is presented as a punishment, or denial of help because the woman "doesn't cooperate" in the way the staff expects, are not acceptable.
Examinations and interventions should be performed with the protection of physical privacy and only in the presence of persons whose presence is necessary.
Conversations about the state of health should not be conducted in such a way that other patients or visitors can hear them unnecessarily. This right is especially important during the loss of a desired pregnancy. A woman should not go through the expulsion of the fetus in a hospital room in front of other patients or without the necessary help and supervision.
Pain is not something a woman must endure to prove strength or cooperation. She has the right to be informed about the expected pain and available methods of alleviating it. If a particular method is not possible or not medically recommended, the reasons should be explained and, when possible, a suitable alternative should be offered. Alleviating suffering does not only mean medication, but also communication, necessary supervision, psychological support and, when conditions allow, support from a close person.
HOW A WOMAN CAN PROTECT HER RIGHTS
If the condition requires emergency care, the priority is to protect health. The patient or a trusted person can request the doctor on duty, the shift manager or the consultation of another doctor, clearly describe the symptoms and request that her statements and request be recorded in the medical documentation.
Once the immediate danger has passed, it is useful to write down the chronology of events as soon as possible: date and time, place, names or descriptions of employees, what was said and done, what complaints were reported and who was present. The discharge list, medical history, reports on interventions, analysis results, records of applied therapy, photos of injuries if any, correspondence and data of possible witnesses should be saved. A note made shortly after the event can help ensure that important details are not forgotten.
The patient has the right to inspect her medical documentation and a copy of it. Documentation is important for continuing treatment, understanding what happened, and possibly initiating a procedure. If there is no information in the documentation about the symptoms she reported, the request she made or the intervention that was implemented, this circumstance should also be mentioned in the complaint.
The first step can be a complaint to the health worker who manages the work process, the director of the health institution. A woman can also contact the adviser for the protection of patients' rights in the city or municipality where the institution is located. The advisor provides information on patients' rights and examines allegations from complaints, and his contact should be displayed in the health facility and available through the local government.
When there are reasons to check the competence of the procedure, he can submit a petition to the health inspection of the Ministry of Health and request an extraordinary external check of the quality of professional work. Depending on the specific case, there may be an appeal to the competent professional chamber, a complaint to the Protector of Citizens or the Commissioner for Information of Public Importance and Protection of Personal Data, a claim for damages and a criminal complaint.
These actions do not have the same goal. A complaint may lead to an internal investigation of the incident and corrective action. Professional supervision checks the quality of work, disciplinary proceedings, the responsibility of the healthcare worker, litigation, the existence of damage and the right to compensation, while in criminal proceedings, it is determined whether a criminal offense has been committed. In complex or difficult cases, it is important to seek legal advice in time, because there are deadlines and special rules of evidence for certain procedures.
The complaint does not have to be written in professional language, nor does the woman have to determine the legal name of the injury herself. It is important to state the institution and department, the date and approximate time of the event, as precise a chronological description as possible, information about the employees if they are known to her, the consequences she suffered, the evidence she is attaching and what she is requesting from the competent authority. It can be an investigation of the event, submission of documentation, determination of responsibility or taking measures to prevent the same behavior from happening again.
WHY IT IS IMPORTANT TO REPORT AN INFRINGEMENT
Women often do not report ill-treatment because they are afraid that no one will believe them, they do not know who to turn to, or they want to avoid further exposure to stress after a difficult experience. Some believe that there is no point in starting the procedure if there is no serious physical consequence. However, the right to dignity, privacy, notice and consent exists regardless of whether permanent bodily harm has occurred.
Opposing obstetric violence is not an attack on health workers or a denial of the difficult conditions in which many of them work. Clear procedures, sufficient staff, good communication, proper documentation and respect for consent protect both patients and conscientious professionals. Reporting bad treatment should therefore not be seen only as a personal conflict with the doctor or institution, but as a way to investigate a specific event and prevent its repetition.
A woman who enters a gynecological-obstetrical clinic does not become just a "case", a "first-born" or a number of beds. She remains a person with the right to be heard, informed and involved in decisions concerning her body. Health care is of high quality only when it is professional, safe and humane at the same time.
The author is a lawyer
Election time! And someone has to report to you independently. That's why it's in October annual subscription the digital edition of "Vremena" even 2.500 dinars cheaper. Choose now!
What is happening in the country and the world, what is in the newspapers and how to pass the time?
Every Wednesday at noon In between arrives by email. It's a pretty solid newsletter, so sign up!
Prisoners in Croatia's largest prison briefly refused to enter their rooms, citing overcrowding and poor conditions. The Minister of Justice admits that overcrowding is a fact, and new prison places have been waiting for years.
Last night, the Ministry of Internal Affairs activated the "Find Me" system for urgent public notification in the case of the disappearance of the ten-year-old boy Boban Đorđević from Velika Plana. The boy was found in Belgrade at the Prokop Railway Station.
How solvent is the Security and Information Agency? Is Serbia condemned to the saying that "everything passes, but only the Service remains"? And that's what the director of Bija, Vladimir Orlić, is bragging about
I can say that we have a rare opportunity to watch on television the epic fall of a regime and media that believed they were unsinkable and invincible. After that, I expect an equally interesting continuation of the program from the Student list, in which we will see how the flyers are vetted
After the election, the international rating agency Fitch Ratings gave the new reality in Serbia an initial loan, but not a blank check. It was established that Serbia has a rating with positive prospects for improvement, supported by macroeconomic stability, as well as solid protection mechanisms. At the same time, the agency emphasized that the economic and fiscal priorities of the new government are not yet clear enough and that the assessment of its economic program will be important for the future development of the rating. Therefore, the attitude towards fiscal discipline, macroeconomic stability, public investments and the continuity of the technocratic character will be much more important than post-election rhetoric.
The four independent members of REM are an example of perseverance and civic responsibility. Rodoljub Šabić even, upon leaving the premises of REM, after the sentencing of the Informer, experienced that the Essenes insulted him, hit him with their hands and feet. But that too will soon be over
Vučić pardoned the batterers and Dijana Hrkalović. The election winners should abolish the sultan's power that allows one man to run afoul of the entire judicial system
Davor Matura's ALTA empire is the transplanted heart of the corrupt regime of Aleksandar Vučić, who was defeated in the October 25 elections. From ALTA Bank, roads lead directly to the top of the progressive government.
The archive of the weekly Vreme includes all our digital editions, since the very beginning of our work. All issues can be downloaded in PDF format, by purchasing the digital edition, or you can read all available texts from the selected issue.